NYT Shares Story of How Journalists Found Ukraine Leaker Before the Deep State – Leads to More Questions than Answers

This morning the Times shared the story behind how its reporters uncovered the leaker of classified information on Ukraine before the Deep State did.  This story provides more questions than answers.

The New York Times shared this morning its story behind how they identified the alleged leaker of classified information on Ukraine.

The murky digital trail started with four items posed to Russian channels on the messaging app Telegram, each consisting of a photograph of a classified U.S. intelligence report. Aric Toler, a freelance reporter who works with us, noticed that several similar documents had also been posted elsewhere and figured that the original source of the leaks had to be somewhere other than Telegram. But he couldn’t find it.

“I looked and looked,” Aric said.

Then a tip came in. Somebody messaged him saying that similar material had appeared on the chat app Discord, in a channel dedicated to maps for the video game Minecraft. Aric found 10 documents there and contacted the host.

The host insisted that he was not the leaker and sounded terrified. Like a lot of the people Aric encountered during the search, the host also seemed to be a teenager. He explained that he had gotten the documents from a chat group called wow_mao on Discord. There, a user named Lucca had posted more than 100 images of leaked documents.

Aric then started livetweeting his research process, and people sent him private messages. He eventually learned that Lucca was part of another chat group — called Thug Shaker Central — where hundreds of documents seemed to have been uploaded. But Thug Shaker Central had vanished, deleted by its users when the leaks became public.

At this point, a former member of Thug Shaker with the user name Vakhi contacted Aric. Lucca was not the original leaker, said Vakhi, who is 17 years old. Somebody known as O.G. was.

Two other Visual Investigations reporters — Christiaan Triebert and Malachy Browne — joined the effort at this point. Working with Aric, they heard from Vakhi that O.G. had started posting the documents to Thug Shaker last fall. O.G. worked at a military facility, Vakhi said, and the two of them had played video games together.

The search was on for O.G.“Thug Shaker was gone, and his fellow gamers refused to identify O.G., but we had enough information to home in on who he might be,” Malachy said. “We looked at the games he played online, who he played them with and connected those dots.”

On Steam, an app that sells video games and where users connect with other players, the reporters looked for Vakhi’s account and for the people to whom he was linked. Aric used a specialized site that scrapes and indexes Steam user data, allowing him to see user names that were associated with Vakhi and his contacts. The team figured that one of the people who had interacted with Vakhi might have been O.G.

The reporters found a such person, with the original user name of jackdjdtex. On the account, they found a screenshot from a video game identifying a player as J Teixeira.

The reporters then scoured Flickr, Instagram and other parts of the web for this mystery person. They found one photo of a Jack Teixeira in a military uniform, another of him smiling in the woods and another of him in the kitchen of his childhood home — standing near a brown-and-white-speckled granite countertop.

On Wednesday, Christiaan and Malachy spoke to another Discord member who had downloaded a new trove of 27 photographs of leaked documents. In some of them, Christiaan and another member of our team, Riley Mellen, noticed that the surface on which the documents were sitting when they were photographed. It was a brown-and-white kitchen countertop.

On Thursday, Haley Willis, another member of our team, and two colleagues arrived before dawn at the Teixeira home in North Dighton, Mass. “We saw who we believe might have been Jack driving into the driveway,” she said. “He saw us, we saw him and his car froze for a second in the driveway.”

They approached the house. Jack’s stepfather, Thomas Dufault, a retired Air Force master sergeant, was there. Haley asked him if she could speak to Jack. “He’s not going to communicate with anybody except an attorney at this point,” the stepfather said. Soon, a plane circled overhead. It was clear the authorities were already on to him.

Back in New York, we published our investigation. Later that morning, a SWAT team arrived at the house in Massachusetts.

This report leads to many questions.

1. Eric Toler is the Director of Training and Research at little-known Bellingcat, a site that appears to focus on Ukraine.  Where did he come from and is this site connected with intelligence in any way?

2. The Washington Post came out with a piece on the leaker on the evening of April 12, which was the evening before the alleged leaker’s arrest.  How did they get the information?  WaPo is known for bogus reporting (e.g. see years of reporting on bogus Trump-Russia collusion) so doesn’t this add less credibility to the case? 

3. The New York Times was at the alleged leaker’s home (Jack Teixeira) the morning of April 13th before the police or Deep State arrived.  How is it that this happened?  Did the NYT know that law enforcement was going to be there that morning like CNN did for Roger Stone’s arrest on bogus charges?

4. Many who looked into this story believed that it was all spun by the MSM and Deep State using NYT, WaPo and other entities as accomplices.  It also showed that the MSM now sides with the Deep State rather than whistleblowers who out the Deep State.

5.  Others point out that the leaks themselves are in question.  No 21-year-old E3 has ever gotten close to this type of info in the past.

6. The info was incomplete missing pages and its focus was on the War in Ukraine.

7. The WaPo reported 300 documents of information that to date have not been located by independent journalists.

There are many questions about this story and the New York Times’s story doesn’t help.  It makes the whole story even muddier than it already is.